Not sure whether to stay on St. Thomas or St. John? Here’s a side-by-side comparison to help you choose your ideal escape. Spoiler: You can enjoy both when you stay at Castle at Cabrita.
ST. THOMAS
If you want a little bit of everything—world-class dining, lively beach bars, historic charm, and easy access to flights—St. Thomas is your spot. You can land at the airport and be sipping a cocktail on your villa terrace in a half hour. Spend your days hopping between iconic beaches like Magens Bay and Lindquist, then head into Red Hook or Charlotte Amalie for a night of fine dining, live music, or dancing to local musicians. There’s always something happening here, and you never have to travel far to find it.
- Best For: Variety, dining, culture
- Access: Direct flights, no ferry needed
- Vibe: Variety of options, convenient, lively
- Top Beaches: Magens Bay, Secret Harbour, Lindquist, Brewers, Sapphire
- Dining & Nightlife: Dozens of bars, fine dining, and live music
- Excursions: Yacht charters, spas, parasailing, historic tours
- Stay Here If: You want both luxury and easy access to everything
ST. JOHN
Just a short ferry ride away, St. John feels like a different world. Two-thirds of the island is protected national parkland, so its beaches and hiking trails are pristine and crowd-free. Imagine waking up to birdsong, spending your morning snorkeling alongside sea turtles at Maho Bay, and your afternoon wandering through tropical forest trails. Evenings here are quieter—perfect for lingering over dinner at a charming, chef-owned restaurant as the sun melts into the horizon.
-
- Best For: Nature lovers, honeymooners, hiking
- Access: Ferry from St. Thomas (15–45 min)
- Vibe: Serene, secluded, unspoiled, National Park exploring
- Top Beaches: Trunk Bay, Maho Bay, Cinnamon Bay
- Dining: Smaller, chef-led restaurants with local charm
- Activities: Snorkeling, hiking, nature photography
- Stay Here If: You want a fully unplugged peace and raw natural beauty
Both islands have their own magic—St. Thomas is lively and convenient, St. John is serene and untouched. But the real beauty? You can easily experience both in one trip.
Why Choose One When You Can Explore Both?
When you stay at Castle at Cabrita, you don’t have to choose.
- You’re just minutes from the St. John ferry
- You’ll enjoy 360° views of St. Thomas, St. John, and the BVI
- Our concierge helps plan day trips, dining, excursions, and more
- Enjoy the privacy of a luxury villa with all the convenience of Red Hook nearby
Ready to chat? Reach out and we’ll help create the perfect island escape for you.





