From Ruins to Radiance — The Rebuild Story of Castle at Cabrita

In September 2017, two of the most powerful Atlantic hurricanes ever recorded — Irma and Maria — swept across the Caribbean just fourteen days apart, each packing sustained winds of over 155 mph. The storms left a trail of devastation, and among the structures battered was the property once known as Villa Fantasia, perched high on Cabrita Point in St. Thomas.

What followed wasn’t just a rebuild — it was a rebirth. A revival born through generational collaboration between a father and daughter, bringing together experience, vision, and love for an extraordinary place. Two storms. Two generations. One redemption story.

A Legacy Worth Rebuilding

Originally constructed in the late 1980s by Thomas, the villa’s original builder and steward of the land, the home was crafted as a gathering place for friends and family — a place where hospitality, laughter, and island beauty came together. For more than three decades, Villa Fantasia stood as a symbol of Caribbean joy.

After the hurricanes, Chelsea — Thomas’s daughter — and her husband Connor knew this wasn’t the end of its story. Partnering closely with Thomas, whose knowledge of every beam and stone was unmatched, Chelsea directed the villa into a new era: blending her fresh perspective with his craftsmanship and the history embedded in its walls. Together, they charted a path to honor the past while designing for the future.

Five Years. One Vision.

What began as a storm-damaged shell evolved into a five-year labor of love. Every wall, beam, and window was reconsidered: how could it remain true to the villa’s original soul while offering an elevated, modern experience?

The result is Castle at Cabrita — a fully reconstructed luxury retreat that pairs timeless Caribbean charm with contemporary elegance, giving guests an immersive sense of comfort and wonder.

A rebuild from the heart of connection

After Hurricanes Irma and Maria in 2017, we chose to treat the rebuild as an invitation to reimagine the heart of the villa — flipping the great room, moving the kitchen into the former living space, and tearing down walls so sightlines sweep a full 360° from anywhere in the room. The kitchen now sits in a spacious elevated outlook overlooking the pool and great room as a conversational hub where guests naturally gather, while the living and dining areas flow together to create an open, airy space made for shared meals, stories, and slow afternoons. It was a big overhaul, but the result is a warm, effortless place designed for connection and the kind of memories families come here to make.

Rising Above: From Torn Roof to Rooftop Retreat

When the storms ripped the roof off in 2017, we saw another chance to rebuild with intention — to honor the villa’s stunning original, gazebo-like interior woodwork while reimagining the rooftop as a place for our guests to truly connect with the unique vantage point of Cabrita Point overlooking the USVI and BVI from one place. We preserved the warm, handcrafted details inside, and added a rooftop deck with a circular couch designed for unobstructed 360° views — perfect for sunrise, sunset, stargazing, and lingering conversations. The new roof keeps the villa’s original charm but elevates the experience: a place where the horizon becomes part of your gathering and every evening feels a little more magical.

The Iconic Rock Room

One of the villa’s most memorable spaces is the Rock Room Suite. From the very beginning, a massive boulder naturally embedded in the hillside inspired the original design. During the rebuild, Chelsea, Connor, and Thomas reimagined how this unique feature could make the space even more inviting. The remodel added a freestanding soaking tub and rainfall shower, turning the room into a sanctuary where nature and design meet in perfect harmony.

Guest Comfort, Above All

Every choice throughout the restoration was guided by two goals: enhancing the guest experience and strengthening the villa to withstand future storms.

Chelsea and Connor now live in a nearby home to welcome guests personally and ensure every stay feels seamless and warm. Thomas continues to visit often, sharing stories and making new memories with his family on the very land he once envisioned as a haven.

Ready to stay somewhere with a story?

Come experience the care, history, and craftsmanship that make Castle at Cabrita so much more than just a vacation rental.

Book your dates today and become part of our legacy.

The Best of Red Hook – Your Guide to Exploring Our Vibrant East End Neighborhood

Just five minutes from the gates of Castle at Cabrita lies one of St. Thomas’s most vibrant and beloved destinations: Red Hook. Tucked along the island’s East End, this buzzing waterfront village is a hub for dining, nightlife, and excursions to nearby islands—making it an essential stop for any luxury traveler looking to mix tropical serenity with vibrant island culture.

Where the Day Begins and Ends

From sun-drenched brunches to moonlit cocktails, Red Hook pulses with island life at every hour. The marina glows at golden hour, the air alive with music and the scent of Caribbean spices.

Dining Delights

Red Hook is a food lover’s playground. Start your morning with a latte at Lattes in Paradise, where marina views and friendly service set the tone for a perfect island day. Or grab an acaii bowl at Tasty to start your morning right with marina views and friendly service set the tone for a perfect island day. Come lunch or dinner, there’s no shortage of unforgettable flavors:

  • The Easterly – Nestled in a lush waterfront setting, this spot serves wood-fired seafood and craft cocktails under twinkling lights. A must for romantic dinners and special celebrations.

  • Hook’d – For laid-back Caribbean vibes, cold drinks, and hearty bites, this is a local go-to right by the ferry dock.

  • RAW Sushi + Sake Bar – A chic, open-air spot for fresh sushi, creative cocktails, and people-watching from above the marina.

Local Shopping

While Red Hook isn’t known for high-end retail, it offers charming finds you won’t want to miss. Explore locally owned boutiques for island jewelry, breezy fashion, and handmade gifts. Shops like Caribbean Surf Co., Ocean Surfari, and Tradewinds Gallery carry beachy essentials and souvenirs that are both beautiful and functional.

Island Adventures

The beating heart of Red Hook is American Yacht Harbor, where adventure is always on deck. From here, you can:

  • Charter a private boat for a day of snorkeling, beach hopping, or sunset cruising

  • Book excursions with trusted local guides:

    • Vibin, Stormy Pirates, and Funhog charters
  • Catch a ferry to St. John or the British Virgin Islands for a day trip filled with new sights and unforgettable beaches

Pop Over to St. John

A short ferry ride from Red Hook brings you to Cruz Bay, the gateway to St. John. Spend the day exploring white sand beaches like Trunk Bay, browsing local art shops, or enjoying tapas and wine with your toes in the sand. It’s a laid-back sister island with a vibe that’s effortlessly cool.

After-Hours Vibes

As the sun sets, Red Hook transforms. Live music spills out of local bars, and the energy is contagious. Grab a signature cocktail at Duffy’s Love Shack, grab a martini at XO, or enjoy a low-key nightcap at Three Palms. Wherever the night takes you, you’ll be met with good vibes and friendly faces.

Why We Love It

Red Hook blends the best of both worlds—laid-back island rhythm with access to everything you could need. It’s the kind of place where you might run into your boat captain at brunch, strike up a conversation with a local artisan, or spontaneously decide to island-hop over a sunset cocktail. And the best part? You’re never more than five minutes from the peace and luxury of Castle at Cabrita.

Book Your Stay

Experience the magic of Red Hook and the serenity of Castle at Cabrita—all in one unforgettable trip.
Check Availability or Contact Us for Planning Help


Best regards,
Chelsea and Connor Stahl
and The Castle at Cabrita Team

What to Pack for Your Luxury Villa Stay in St. Thomas

You’ve officially booked the dream vacation—a stay at Castle at Cabrita, perched high above the Caribbean with views that will stop you in your tracks. Now comes the fun part: packing!

While our villa includes just about everything to make your stay seamless, it helps to come prepared for everything from sun-soaked beach days to rooftop wine nights under the stars. Whether you’re planning on snorkeling from your private beach or enjoying a candlelit dinner by a private chef, here’s your go-to packing guide to make the most of your time in island luxury.

1. BREEZY ISLAND ATTIRE

When in the Virgin Islands, it’s all about embracing the breeze and sunshine! Think lightweight fabrics, linen shirts, easy sundresses, and swim cover-ups you can throw on between the pool and brunch. Bring something elevated too—we’re talking resort casual for dinner out in Red Hook or a stylish evening in with your private chef. And don’t forget a cozy wrap or light sweater for those breezy terrace evenings with a glass of rosé in hand.

2. MULTIPLE SWIMSUITS

One is never enough! You’ll want at least 2–3 swimsuits in rotation, especially if your days are filled with dips in the infinity pool, beach time at Secret Harbour, or snorkeling at nearby Sapphire Bay. Pro tip: pack a mix of styles—something comfortable for water adventures and something chic for sunbathing on the deck.

3. REEF-SAFE SUNSCREEN & AFTER-SUN CARE

In the U.S. Virgin Islands, reef-safe sunscreen is more than just a good idea—it’s required by law to help protect our vibrant marine life. Look for mineral-based brands (zinc oxide or titanium dioxide), and pair it with aloe gel or after-sun lotion to soothe your skin after long hours of salty, sunny fun. We also recommend a wide-brim hat and a great pair of sunglasses for added UV protection.

4. WATER SHOES OR SANDALS WITH GRIP

Island life doesn’t mean flip-flops all the time (although they are handy!). Bring water shoes or grippy sandals for rocky beaches and snorkel adventures, and a comfy pair of walking shoes if you plan to explore historical sites, hike in St. John, or shop around Charlotte Amalie. A cute sandal or espadrille is perfect for dinner outings or cocktails on the villa terrace.

5. WATERPROOF BAGS & TECH PROTECTION

Protect your devices and belongings with a dry bag, especially if you’re planning any boating excursions or island hopping to the BVIs. A small waterproof pouch is also a great idea for keeping your phone safe during beach days.

6. SOMETHINGS SPECIAL FOR SUNSET

Sunsets at Castle at Cabrita are next level—fiery skies over St. John and soft breezes from the sea. Bring a special outfit or a favorite playlist, and settle in for golden hour with your drink of choice. Whether it’s a sunset toast on the rooftop or a cozy evening under the string lights, you’ll want to be camera-ready (or not—it’s your vacation after all!).

At Castle at Cabrita, we make island luxury feel effortless.
We’ve got the setting and the essentials covered—so all you need to pack are the pieces that help you feel your best. Think beach-ready, sunset-worthy, and adventure-approved.

Book your stay or get in touch.

Best regards,
Chelsea and Connor Stahl
and The Castle at Cabrita Team

Things to do on St. Thomas for Memorial Day Weekend

Memorial Day weekend is a popular time to visit St. Thomas, as the island comes alive with a variety of events and activities. Whether you’re looking for something cultural, athletic, or just plain fun, there’s something for everyone during this holiday weekend.

Here are some of the things to do on St. Thomas during Memorial Day weekend:

  1. Memorial Day Ceremonies: St. Thomas hosts several ceremonies and events to honor those who have served in the military and made the ultimate sacrifice for their country. The American Legion, VFW, and other organizations typically hold wreath-laying ceremonies, parades, and other tributes throughout the weekend.
  2. Beach Parties: St. Thomas is home to some of the most beautiful beaches in the Caribbean, and what better way to celebrate the holiday than by soaking up the sun and partying with friends? Many of the island’s popular beaches, such as Magens Bay and Sapphire Beach, will host Memorial Day parties with live music, food, and drinks.
  3. Local Music: St. Thomas is known for its vibrant music scene, and Memorial Day weekend is no exception. The island hosts several live music events at locations including Roots Garden Lounge, Sapphire Beach Bar, Hooked USVI, Bernies, and more the weekend, featuring local and international artists. The Carnival Village in Charlotte Amalie is a popular venue for live music, as well as the Cruz Bay Landing on neighboring St. John.
  4. Food and Drink Festivals: Memorial Day weekend is a great time to sample the island’s diverse culinary offerings. Many restaurants and bars will offer special menus and deals, and there are several food and drink festivals that take place throughout the weekend. Enjoy a Sunday brunch at amazing local restaurants like Old Stone Farmhouse, Caribbean Fish Market, and The Social.
  5. Boat Tours: St. Thomas is surrounded by crystal-clear waters, and there’s no better way to explore the island’s coastline than by boat. Many tour companies offer Memorial Day weekend specials on boat tours, including snorkeling trips, sunset cruises, and island-hopping excursions.

Memorial Day weekend is a great time to visit St. Thomas, as the island offers a variety of events and activities to suit all interests. Whether you’re looking to honor the holiday’s significance, party on the beach, or explore the island’s cultural offerings, there’s something for everyone on this beautiful Caribbean island. When you stay with Castle at Cabrita you will have a personal concierge to help plan the perfect vacation for you and your family!

St. Thomas Carnival

Are you planning a trip to St. Thomas during the Carnival season? If so, you’re in for a real treat! The Carnival in St. Thomas is a cultural explosion of music, dance, and colorful costumes, and it’s the perfect time to experience the island’s vibrant culture.

St. Thomas Carnival is one of the most popular and festive events in the Caribbean, and it’s been celebrated for over 100 years. The festivities start in April and continue for a month, culminating in a parade called the “Adult’s Parade” that takes place in Charlotte Amalie on April 29th.

If you’re visiting St. Thomas for the Carnival, here are some of the things you can do to make the most of your experience:

Attend the Carnival Village: This is the epicenter of the Carnival celebrations, where you’ll find food stalls, craft vendors, and live music performances. You’ll get a chance to taste local cuisine and drinks, shop for souvenirs, and immerse yourself in the festive atmosphere.

Watch the J’ouvert: This is an early morning parade that starts around 4 am and lasts until sunrise. Participants wear colorful costumes and cover themselves in paint and mud, and it’s a lively and energetic celebration of Caribbean culture.

Enjoy the food and drinks: St. Thomas is famous for its delicious cuisine, and during Carnival, you’ll find a wide variety of local dishes to try, including fried fish, conch fritters, and johnnycakes. Don’t forget to try the island’s signature cocktail, the Painkiller, made with rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and coconut cream.

Explore the island: While the Carnival celebrations are the main attraction, St. Thomas has plenty of other things to see and do. You can take a scenic drive around the island, visit historical sites like Blackbeard’s Castle and Fort Christian, or spend a day at one of the island’s beautiful beaches.

Overall, St. Thomas Carnival is a fantastic time to visit the island and experience its unique culture. Whether you’re interested in music, dance, food, or history, there’s something for everyone at the Carnival. So pack your bags, put on your dancing shoes, and get ready for an unforgettable experience!